Crazy Horse’s Vision

Crazy Horse’s Vision. Joseph Bruchac. Illus. by S.D. Nelson. New York: Lee & Low Books, Inc, 2000. 32 pages. $16.95 (Hardcover). ISBN 1-880000-94-6. Grades 2-5.

At eleven winters old he tamed a wild mare. At thirteen he killed his first buffalo and offered it to “all those in camp who have no one to hunt for them.” When trouble came to the Lakotas it was no surprise that the boy once known as Curly rose to the occasion. Together author Joseph Bruchac and illustrator S.D. Nelson share the story of how Curly, the son of Tashunka Witco came in to his father’s name after interpreting a vision sent to help him lead his people. This rich interpretation of Lakota history not only exhibits the pride and strength of the people it tells of, but teaches readers of the people who lived before them. The full paged acrylic illustrations blend color, texture, and perspectives from modern art as well as that of the author’s Sioux ancestors. Bruchac’s words flow from the page as readers learn about and come to admire the man most commonly known as Crazy Horse. The story is further enriched by the author’s and illustrator’s notes included at the back of the book that delve further in to Lakota culture and history. Crazy Horse’s Vision is not only culturally enriching, but a timeless and fascinating story.  Highly Recommended

My Thoughts…

I have never really read any Native American literature before, so I wasn’t sure what to expect when I cracked open this book. I was not surprised, however, to find tradition and honor, respect and strength represented in the story. I initially enjoyed the story as a story and didn’t know if any of the pieces were factual. After reading the author’s and illustrator’s notes, however, I appreciated it even more because although the plot may not be completely true, it isn’t necessarily false either. I do think this would be a great book to use at a story time or in a classroom because there is adventure and history. The illustrations were great, and I was thrilled that both the writer and illustrator identify with the Lakota people. I think that fact made the story and art more genuine. I am now looking forward to reading more Native American literature as the summer progresses!  

Potential Reaction…

I think boys will love this book, but that everyone will enjoy that fact that there is a hero who has a vision. Visions are mystical and not a part of today’s culture, and in Native American culture they are incredibly important. I think today’s readers will ask questions and be interested in the concept of being led by a higher being and seeing signs. I also think the accomplishments of Crazy Horse will spark talk amongst children about their strengths and how they would have helped their people had it been them. I think though, rather than just being entertaining, children will become interested in Native American history and culture. I can imagine that children would be upset to hear that the white men attacked the Lakotas even though they tried to make the situation right. There is definitely grounds for good conversation here.

Reminds Me Of…

Unfortunately I have ready very few stories about any Native American tribes and am only really familiar with Disney’s Pocahontas. Therefore I cannot compare this book in terms of cultural representation or style. It does remind me, however, of stories of mainstream cultural icons that we learn about as children. I know I have read or been read stories about Johnny Appleseed and how his name came to be and all the good he did. I feel that this style story is similar, but different.